Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ray Watford's avatar

I love the Stockdale Paradox The Stockdale Paradox highlights a powerful truth: the balance between hope and realism. Optimistic pessimism acknowledges reality without losing resolve. Blind optimism leaves you unprepared, while pessimism saps motivation. By preparing for the worst, you gain confidence to handle any outcome, fostering genuine, grounded hope. This balance turns adversity into a challenge, not a defeat.

Expand full comment
Cleve Johnson's avatar

Regarding “Sphexishness is when you blindly follow a rule without checking if the rule works in the present situation.”

I once thought that people who did the above weren’t very smart and lead the unexamined lives that Throeau wrote of. Then I read about a primitive society that went through a 26 step process to prepare an important part of their diet (I can’t remember what book I read about this in). They had been doing this so for many generations that nobody alive knew what the original reason for procedure was. Turns out that the plant they were eating was toxic and all 26 steps were necessary to detoxify it. In other words, mindless conformity kept them fed and alive.

This also brings to mind a well known quote from G.K. Chesterton: “Don’t remove a fence until you understand why it was put there.” Unfortunately, there are things about the past that we may never know.

There is also not time enough in life to examine everything thoroughly. One must pick and choose what one wants to examine. Time spent examining x is time that can’t be spent doing y.

Expand full comment
90 more comments...

No posts